← All conversationsThe Breakthrough Moment Podcast

Bianca Raby

The Problem With AI in Education Nobody Is Saying

With Zac Deane/Technology & AI / Health & Wellbeing / Business & Leadership
53:18 Hosted by Zac DeaneWatch on YouTube
The conversation

About this episode

Bianca Raby has spent 20 years redesigning education for institutions like Melbourne Business School and the Australian Institute of Sport. In this episode she breaks down what AI is actually doing to learning, why writing equals thinking, and what every educator and leader needs to understand right now.

Explore the episode

Episode notes

  1. 00:00Welcome and guest introduction
  2. 02:04Bianca's breakthrough moment: applying to Melbourne Business School from the middle of nowhere
  3. 04:30Standing in the hallways asking strangers to explain what they did for a living
  4. 05:28What education actually means and why most people never truly transform
  5. 07:00Why she chose the biggest MBA in Australia to rebrand from teacher to founder
  6. 08:37The entrepreneur that was fighting its way out through the education system
  7. 10:20If you could go back: she would have jumped into business years earlier
  8. 13:00Own your superpowers and stay in your lane
  9. 13:20What OPEDA is, where it came from, and the missing piece in higher education
  10. 16:30AI literacy explained: participation, judgment, and responsibility
  11. 17:00Teachers are no longer facilitators. They are thinking partners.
  12. 19:00AI is burning away the administration burden and giving educators their brain space back
  13. 25:00We are all learning for the first time. There are no experts in this.
  14. 28:00Writing equals thinking and why outsourcing it is costing you more than you think
  15. 34:27AI did not raise the ceiling. It just let everyone get to average.
  16. 36:30People always find each other again. AI will not replace the human in the loop.
  17. 42:00The calculator was going to kill maths. It did not. AI is the same.
  18. 44:00What AI tools Bianca actually uses and why she named hers Todd
  19. 50:56The breakthrough challenge: change your environment and something will change

Chapter titles and timings from the published YouTube description.

In their own words

From the conversation

Excerpts from YouTube automatic captions. They may contain transcription errors. Play a timestamp to hear the original conversation.

02:05

Bianca's breakthrough moment: applying to Melbourne Business School from the middle of nowhere

like. How many have you got? Yeah, I mean I think um I think I've had multiple I mean most entrepreneurs have. I mean we we don't get here by accident. Um and often it's it's not a straight line. Um so I think probably connected to this conversation today, one of my biggest great breakthrough moments was um turning up and and starting my MBA. Um so I was a school teacher um trained as a school teacher, you know, grew up in a very small country town similar size to Wala actually. um and was quite institutionalized up ...

07:00

Why she chose the biggest MBA in Australia to rebrand from teacher to founder

podcast.io. Now, let's get back to the episode. Then, >> I think the first thing is that you've just got to take a step outside of your comfort zone. If you don't step outside of your comfort zone and if you do as we always have done, you will always get what you've always got. So, you know, education is exactly that it the key to education is transformation. So, a lot of people talk about being lifelong learners and all of that, but let not very many people actually transform. And education is actually about transforming from one state ...

13:22

What OPEDA is, where it came from, and the missing piece in higher education

mistakes as I've made in the last seven years. Um, but you know, take all those learnings and and kind of do it do it again because I love what we do. We work with people to take an idea and to get it into a transformational piece and that's that's important. So, >> okay. Interesting. Tell us more about that. So, was I'm guessing did you have a breakthrough moment with is it Opta? Is that I pronounce it correctly? >> Uh, yeah. What does that what does that even mean? And what was the breakthrough moment starting this? ...

19:01

AI is burning away the administration burden and giving educators their brain space back

tools. So we have to install in our learners how to think and we have to keep that foundational stuff. So educators now have to a have their own personal judgment about how they're using AI and they need to model that and be able to explain that and then be able to think through the use of these tools in their classroom context with their learners and equip their learners to be able to come out into the real world and think through that in a in a conscious way. >> Wow. Thinking partners. Who invented that word? That ...

36:33

People always find each other again. AI will not replace the human in the loop.

A. So for example, I'll give it like terms an A before LLMs in a school. So just go with letters. An A or a HD. Now most students in the class can get to that A because they have a tool that gets them there. So we didn't AI hasn't done this. It just let everybody get to the top. Right? This is why we have >> we were already aiming. We were already aiming for as high as we could get to. And now it's it's allowing more people to get to the top. >> Exactly. So it's ...

Read the episode transcript

YouTube automatic captions. Names, punctuation and wording may contain transcription errors.

00:01

Welcome back everybody to the breakthrough moment podcast. We interview successful entrepreneurs and investors and ask them what is their biggest breakthrough moment in their career. The moment that changed it all, took them into another level of success or impact or insight and as they share that moment with us, us at home have breakthroughs as well. I'm Zach Dean with Biana Rabi. How are you? >> Where are you tuning in from? >> Yeah, I'm tuning in from Adelaide, South Australia. So, it's very cold here. Not like your your location. >> Okay. I know. I just got out of the sun. It's boiling here in Dubai. My family is from from Wya, South Australia. >> Oh, nice. There you go. >> So, uh it's the road. >> Yeah, exactly. Well, great to meet you and I'm really excited to introduce you to everybody. You're doing some big big things and uh everybody at home is in for a treat. So, let's let's I'll start with the introduction and then we'll dive into your breakthrough moment. Okay. So let me start. So everybody at home, most people think the future of education is about better technology, right? Better tech, better AI, better automations. It's debatable. And so Bianca will tell you it's all about better teachers. With over 20 years redesigning and delivering learning, she has founded Opida, which has worked with some of Australia's most high stakes institutions like Melbourne Business School, Delta Department of Defense, and the Australian Institute of Sports. She holds an MBA, runs a YouTube channel, writes, speaks, and is one of the most respected voices in AI literacy for education today. her belief, no policy changes a classroom. Only the person or the people standing in it does. Stay to the end where we're going to be walking through some unique educational frameworks. Uh if you like to really dive into we'll put your educator hat on. We'll be diving into those. But Bianca, welcome to the Breakthrough Moment podcast. Let's start with your breakthrough moment. What >> which one do we want to pick? [laughter] >> Yeah, you could share as many as you like. How many have you got? Yeah, I mean I think um I think I've had multiple I mean most entrepreneurs have. I mean we we don't get here by accident. Um and often it's it's not a straight line. Um so I think probably connected to this conversation today, one of my biggest great breakthrough moments was um turning up and and starting my MBA. Um so I was a school teacher um trained as a school teacher, you know, grew up in a very small country town similar size to Wala actually. um and was quite institutionalized up until about the age of 28 when I decided to go to the big city of Melbourne and uh and embark on my MBA. So I'd say um for my story today that's one of the most significant decisions that I made around my career which has landed me in the position that I am fortunate to be in which is to talk about education in a way that reaches a lot more people than a 28 room classroom. And so as much as I love teaching and I loved the students and I loved schools, I really just felt like I had um I really wanted to work with the

03:02

system and I wanted to work in a broader sense and work from the outside in. I wasn't um a very good employee as you would say. Most entrepreneurs find it very difficult to work in a system and I was one of those and I think I realized that around 28 and then I took myself off. I was living in Gapawak if anyone knows Northern Territory in Anamland. It is about 850 km from Darwin. I was living in a um teacher house. I had a four-wheel drive that I had to drive out through crossings. It was a dry community. It was 2 hours from the local Worths and I was living out there and I was thinking, you know what? It's time for a change. I've always wanted to do a business degree. So, I applied naively to Melbourne Business School. I'm thinking that just, you know, like my undergrad, if I apply, I'd get in. [laughter] and um naively just sent the application and and kind of started telling everybody I was going um and then found out that actually you needed an interview. Um and so I got my interview a couple months later or actually I think it was only a month or so they kept me waiting and then they said I was accepted and that's when I realized I was actually in an interview process. So that was kind of interesting because I just had this blind optimism that I was going and I was just deciding to do this and that was the next step. Um, and so I turned up in Melbourne in January of 2013. Um, very naive to what the rest of the world does. I would been an institutionalized educator. So that means I'd been at school, went to school to go back to school. And all I'd really known is school and school systems. And I stood in the hallways of Melbourne Business School, very daunting space. And I'm standing there next to people who had been working for the big corporates, who were already in seuite jobs, who were engineers, who were doing jobs. I had no clue what they meant. I was like, "What does a business development manager do?" And I actually asked at least 10 people in those first few months. I get you've got a title. Can you tell me what happens in your day? And I'd asked them to break it down to me cuz I had absolutely no idea what the rest of the world did. I just knew what learning and education and schools were. So that was a huge moment for me because it was probably my first big awakening also to the economy, the way the world works, the way finance works, the way business works and uh yeah, it's kind of led me exactly where I am today. If I hadn't have done that, I wouldn't be here. >> Yeah. Interesting. The power of education. I think there's uh there's two lines in the sand or there's two directions or roads that we can go down in life. is like uh to and the massive forks in the road so to speak which is like those especially from the podcast they say the biggest defining factor of where they are today is because of education whether it's from you know a schooling education or a mentor or or work experience is that that education is so so important especially looking at and interviewing some people from like third world countries like India and things like this education is such a massive differentiator for their culture Indeed. What advice do you have for maybe some people out there who maybe do feel

06:01

sheltered or haven't really experienced the world and they they're wanting to expand their horizon so to speak and or they're considering education or considering I guess different options to get out of their little village or or town. What would you say to real quick before we continue? A brief message from today's sponsor. If you're an entrepreneur wanting to grow your personal brand, authority, and business through podcasting, then check out finderodcast.io. As you know, the biggest entrepreneurs in the world, they book these massive podcast tours before a big product launch or an event or book because podcasts build trust faster than anything else online today. So, it's find.io. It helps you connect with a specific podcast in your niche. It writes the pitch, it follows up in this easy CRM. It truly does save time. So, you just show up, do the podcast, and your business grows. If you're curious to learn more, book in a demo at find a podcast.io. Now, let's get back to the episode. Then, >> I think the first thing is that you've just got to take a step outside of your comfort zone. If you don't step outside of your comfort zone and if you do as we always have done, you will always get what you've always got. So, you know, education is exactly that it the key to education is transformation. So, a lot of people talk about being lifelong learners and all of that, but let not very many people actually transform. And education is actually about transforming from one state to another. And so if you're wanting to embark on education, you should be doing it from a place of I'm actually up for challenging myself and I'm going to transform in and I'm going to be in a different state at the end of it. If you don't get that out of your educational program or course or whatever it is you choose to do, then there's something's going to miss. You should be different from when you started. And so if you are looking for a different life, you have to start doing different things. So it would could just be a short course on the weekends. it could just or or you do what I do and you just go all in, right? So, I went for the biggest top MBA in Australia by accident without consideration just cuz I knew that I wanted to do a business degree and I was a school teacher and I needed to be rebranded. So, I went for a big name because I needed to be rebranded because not a lot of people can see a teacher doing a lot of other things. We kind of get boxed in pretty fast. So, I knew I needed, you know, not just an online course. I needed to be at the school networking and so I did. I met everybody I could. I went to every event I could. I had a thousand mini kiches and all of those things you do. I I did the whole circuit of the Melbourne startup scene. And for four years, I just threw myself into everything business. I read all the books. I went to the to talks. I learned and I met all the people. And I did that because I was shifting my I wanted to shift my entire personal brand and my career from one state to another. And so it wasn't just the program that I went into. It was how I went into that program. I took every opportunity to to rebrand. And so that's

09:00

what I say to people. Don't just turn up and expect the course to do all the work for you. You have to kind of join as well. >> For sure. It sounds like you were quite strategic. Is that a mindset that you had before schooling or from parents or mentors or was that what you learned at school like think ahead strategize or is that just like natural instinct? >> Um it was funny. I don't think I was too strategic in how I chose the MBA, but I guess I just went off intuition. Like I I knew there was an entrepreneur in me and it was it was fighting its way out through the education space I was in. I was constantly adopting technology. This is how it kind of leads to where I am now. So I was constantly looking for ways to do everything better. I I just literally the first ABN I registered was actually a company called Be Better and it kind of encompassed like I didn't actually use that brand ever in the market but it was kind of how I thought about everything like can we do this better? Can we do this better? And so I had this entrepreneurial part of me and this problem solver in me I think that was sort of inbuilt into my character and then of course you know once that starts to be applied and you start to see results from that you start to kind of be encouraged by your own personality and kind of keep going. So I think it wasn't so much as a strategy more so that I was going to put my life on hold and opportunity cost of everything and my salary and it cost an absolute fortune when it comes to dollar and bunny and opportunity cost. If I was going to do that, I've got to take what I can from it to make sure it actually sets me up for the next bit, you know. So it was really I think it was just a case of bit of my character and a bit of the the marketplace that I was in. I knew that business is all about relationships. So >> super important. Hypothetically, you could go back in time and start your educational journey again. >> What would you do different? >> Oh, I would have done the MBA so much faster. I would have got Yeah, I wanted I graduated from my education degree, got into the classroom, did a year and wanted to leave and do business and I stayed uh another six years um in the system. And look, I don't regret that time as in like I got a lot of experience and it taught me a lot of things about working in sight of systems. However, you know, there's a part of me that wishes I'd, you know, jumped into business earlier than I did. So, because yeah, I love it. >> Well, for sure. For sure. Oh, it's uh and and what about now? Like you're you're you're in it. You're in the technology. You're in the education space. You've been, you know, you've got your successful company and worked for some amazing other companies. If you were to I know this is like just this is a random question I love asking. It's like if you were to start again, right, start your company from scratch, what would you do? Would you choose AI? Would you choose education? Like if you were to launch again, what would you do? >> Depends what day you ask me, Zach. Like today, I'm feeling pretty positive. I've had a really good day today. Um, made a couple of sales and had some really interesting conversations, but if you'd asked me a week ago, probably would have said I'd start a coffee shop and stuff this internet [laughter] So, yeah, I mean, honestly, it depends on the day. I look, I this is one of the things that actually came out of the MBA. So when I was in it, there was a

12:02

lot of um I had a lot of dissonance around. I didn't know whether I was in the MBA so that I could get out of education or I was in the MBA to stay in education. And so there was a part of me that was dreaming of changing my life really in drastically and just getting out of that teacher educator kind of thing. And then I had all these, you know, fantasies about going to work for some corporate in a brand because I did really well in brand management. I loved brand management. the strategy of it just really suited me and I could see myself going in and doing this and doing that and brand. But the problem is once you're an educator, you're always an educator. It's in your blood. It was in my blood when I was born. I didn't choose this per se. It just kind of, you know, it it just is my character. So even though I tried to like go and get these other jobs and other opportunities, I always came back to communicating, educating, guiding, teaching, facilitating, like that was always going to be where I landed. So then there was a realization of like, okay, just own your own your superpowers and own your lane. Stay in your lane and just use all these new skills to do what you do better. So yes, the coffee shop sounds great in a nice lovely area where everybody comes in and says good morning and you have this nice community and you know all of that, but it's not really me. So yeah, no. Would I start it? What would I do? I'd probably start this business again. maybe not make as many mistakes as I've made in the last seven years. Um, but you know, take all those learnings and and kind of do it do it again because I love what we do. We work with people to take an idea and to get it into a transformational piece and that's that's important. So, >> okay. Interesting. Tell us more about that. So, was I'm guessing did you have a breakthrough moment with is it Opta? Is that I pronounce it correctly? >> Uh, yeah. What does that what does that even mean? And what was the breakthrough moment starting this? >> I think it was it was accumulating for years. I'd kind of worked in consulting and I'd worked in some online business school and I'd done a lot of work with um organizations around uplifting the uplifting the way they do education. I'd seen a lot of crap. I'd seen a lot of ways we could do be better. Um and I'd basically started to really understand that role of teacher with the like the academics and the educators in the higher education space. So I'd come from K to2 and I landed in higher ed and I saw that of course in the higher ed space in Australia exact they don't have to be teachers. is they don't have to have teacher training. They're subject matter experts and they go and teach. And so there's a big missing piece of pedagogy there which you know people like myself who understand technology, who understand academia can bridge for them. And so that's where it all came from. And then I was wanting to build a location independent lifestyle. And so I decided that obviously online learning was going to be a good idea because I saw a lot of that happening. But I saw just a lot of PowerPoint slides being put up in LMS's and being called courses and that's not a course. That's not a learning experience and that's really not going to get that transformation. So um over the years of working in Melbourne for a few people I saw the

15:00

market and I said you know what the piece that I love the most is the design piece because when I was in the classroom the piece I loved the most was the lesson planning. I loved thinking through how I was going to teach this concept and that was my favorite part was like how do I creatively bring this to life for the kids today and then obviously going in and delivering it is super fun too but for me it was around that design piece so OPA came out of the idea that hey if we just do this one thing really really well and that's online learning design we can raise the bar in the quality of the education which of course over time starts to mean that our consumers our students start to be more sophisticated ated investors and they start to demand more from the institutions because in education, higher education, you have a very it's not a it's not an open market. You know, you have students that are funneled in because that's the way the system works and they're not always sophisticated investors. It's not the same as any other product where the investor can go and make other choices. Online has disrupted that because institutions now have to compete with other pe other institutions across the world. So that was great because that started a competition and it started to say well actually you need to do a better quality product because you're competing now with you know Bendigo University or Bendigo TA over here and you need to be better right so that was exciting and this all happened at about the same time as the market was starting to shift online was happening I had the business thing and I thought we need to help institutions do this better because they're going to be under pressure for a very long time to get digital their educa digital education footprint um you know to a higher quality because they're going to have to compete >> for sure. I read one of your posts you you talk about AI literacy for educators is about participation, judgment, and responsibility. What does that actually look like? Um can you give us an example just quickly before we continue? If you're an entrepreneur out there or a high performer who wants more clarity and direction in life or maybe you're going through some kind of turbulent transitional phase, I want to share with you something that I co-built. It's called the life blueprint system. It's an AI powered goal setting process that helps you create a personalized life blueprint. Kind of like an architectural plan or a business plan but for your life. And so it allows you to take and capture those big ideas, those those amazing thoughts you have and to turn it into a proven plan of action. And so if you want to stop guessing and start building your future intentionally and consciously, go to the lifebloopprint.io to learn more. Let's go back to the episode. >> Yeah. So, I think AI right now is disrupting education in the best possible way. I think I've been I'm pretty excited by it to be to be honest. Um I know that there's people working in education, I'll acknowledge it right now, that are feeling really overwhelmed and I get that and I think we all are in our own respective fields. But what I'm excited about with the AI literacy piece and what AI is doing to education is it's really making us ask the question, what are we actually assessing? What are we actually teaching? And we've really changed our roles a lot. And so people talk about the rapid change in technology and it's true the the amount

18:02

of change that these technologies have had in the last 25 years. The rate of change has never been so rapid and therefore the roles are shifting faster than we can even put our fingers on it. So what I like to talk to teachers about at the moment is that they have their new role which has started about a couple of years ago but it's really starting to really form now is they are thinking partners. They're not facilitators anymore. So we went from being kind of we held the knowledge then we started to curate and help the students engage with the knowledge. We started facilitating the knowledge and now we're becoming thinking partners because we need to really start thinking about what exactly are we asking the learner to do and what is the output now and the output now is not necessarily just more writing or more speaking or more text. The output is going to be about how we think about problems and what kind of learners do we want because we all knowledge has been democratized and now we also have thinking that's being taken away from us with these tools. So we have to install in our learners how to think and we have to keep that foundational stuff. So educators now have to a have their own personal judgment about how they're using AI and they need to model that and be able to explain that and then be able to think through the use of these tools in their classroom context with their learners and equip their learners to be able to come out into the real world and think through that in a in a conscious way. >> Wow. Thinking partners. Who invented that word? That is must have been an Australian >> maybe. [laughter] But yeah, we we we just we have to I mean we're not asking there's no there's no longer we can just say produce me this because AI can produce this. You have to be able to produce this and tell me how you produce this, why you produce this, and what you might do differently. And that's a whole other set of cognition skills. And so we we've been saying for a long time we need to teach our kids critical thinking. Every adult thinks that you know teach critical thinking. Critical thinking only comes from a place when you have domain expertise. You can't teach critical thinking when you don't have that domain expertise because you can't read a chat GPT response if you don't understand the content and go oh that doesn't sound right because you don't know the content. So we can't just slap a critical thinking layer on this and go uh tell the kids to you know read it and does it sound too good to be true well to in compared to what right so we need to add these layers of cognition and metacognition is super important too the thinking about thinking and this is a pl piece that we've always wanted to get to with as educators so back to why I'm so excited educators are constantly bombarded with dumb administration and we've had that problem for a very long time there's a lot of admin administrative burden of working in a system. AI is now giving us an opportunity to kind of wipe some of that out. And if that administration starts to leave and starts to get automated and starts to be simplified, ideally in a in a really good conscious school or

21:02

institution, you will then have your teachers and educators having brain space and the cognitive power to go and actually take on these bigger tasks with their learners. They'll have more time to talk, to sit, to learn together, to reflect, to do all the things we know that learning is about. Often a school or an institution is covered up with all this other stuff and then the learning gets the last priority. But we get a chance to kind of tidy all that up and get back to the point, which is to have people in a room learning together, reflecting, thinking about their thinking, and helping each other be critical. >> Very important. It's it's yeah, I'm really enjoying this conversation. This is like I I think a lot of the time that I meet other AI experts or or people that are I guess talking about the advances in technology, there is definitely a um like a calming energy that they actually bring to it because I think anything that's misunderstood is typically like rejected. And I think a lot of the stuff on social media is very um like clickbaited or like propaganda or like a lot of fear and it's going to change this and restructure the workforce and obviously which I guess it is but I think it's dramatized a little bit. If you have a business on Facebook or Instagram, you need to learn about this new amazing AI automation tool. The question is, is your personal profile or business profile manually messaging your target audience every single day? If not, I highly recommend you do this. There's a massive ROI on that. But if you are, there's a more cost effective strategy. So, this is a unique AI software. It runs for you, your friend requests, the messages, the likes, even the comments 24/7 in the cloud. So, while you're watching podcasts like this or taking calls or while you're sleeping, it's running there in the background. Some of these people are pulling in another 5 to 20 extra qualified leads every single week on autopilot. You can experience the podcast special trial and try it for yourself today. Check it out in the show notes below. >> Um, >> it is for the better. I mean, this is the thing. We always assume that change is for the worst and change is bad. And I'm like, we've been waiting for this kind of change in education for a long time. I I can't tell you how many times that I've been on a soap box about assessment design, about, you know, what are we actually teaching, constructive alignment. I'm just throwing out, you know, pedagogy words for you for your for your listeners, but like how many times have we been talking about system design and system challenges and everybody who's worked in the system says the same thing. We need change, right? We have this thing now that's like this little, you know, AI kind of scary alien and it's it's able to do lots of things like it is going to cause some destruction. It has to every disruptive technology does disrupt for a reason and it causes a little bit of destruction. But we can also consciously move into this space with a hang on a minute, but actually this could actually cause destruction for the better because it means we have to rethink how our

24:00

systems work. Often it's our systems that get in the way of our learners, not the teachers themselves. And they will tell you that they want to do X, Y, and Zed, but they can't because the system says no. So if we get to rethink how the system works, we get to rethink what the teachers and learners can do. >> So it's exciting. >> That is exciting. Hopefully teachers can get paid more. pay. They're one of the most important parts of society yet paid pretty average from my understanding. >> Um, does this make sense to to share this evolution of the teacher role now then? >> Yeah, you can bring it up if if it um yeah, see if it makes sense to your audience. I think it sort of goes to that point before that we've seen so much change. So, pre995, you know, we were the experts. Um then we became guides then we became facilitators and we became guides in that time because we started to get some digital access to knowledge. So this is when we had our computers and enarter and all those things that we got on our computers when we were in primary school. I think you're and Zach you and I are almost the same age. So primary school we had like things like that. We were getting it was there was encyclopedias around but there was a bit of digital stuff happening and it was a lot more like oh this is when we started talking about validity of sources you know. So this is like guiding you through where the information is. 2010 hit. That's when YouTube hit the market. YouTube is the biggest educational platform on the planet. Like it really is. And no educator was part of designing it. And it's the biggest it is the biggest platform on the planet because it serves a just in time purpose and it allows you to personalize your journey and it curates to your liking and you can go and choose your own adventure. So those two things alone should tell us a little bit about how adults learn and how people learn. Right? So we became facilitators in 2010. We became facilitators of the knowledge out there. We started to help people curate their own understanding and they access the internet. And so just recently this is why we're still grappling with it. And there's a lot of you know people with head in their hands. We turned into these thinking partners because this is how and this is why it's so important. So we talk about AI literacy for the whole person. And that is because we want the teacher and the educator to have that literacy because they have to model it. Now it's not enough just to say do this, do that. There is a modeling effect and the way that we teach our young people how to think through this new technology is by doing it ourselves and then working with them. We're all learning together at the moment. There is no experts in this, right? There are some of us who live and breathe this content a bit more in each day and so we have lots of opinions, but none of us are experts in this. We're all learning for the first time how this technology is actually going to affect us. And so that's why I'm hugely advocating right now for real personal responsibility when it comes to your own AI use and being conscious as not as much as you can about how it is affecting your thinking. So if you're overrelying on it and you're cognitively outsourcing it, you need to step back and make your own strategies to stop doing that so that you can regulate because no one's going to come do it for you. The tech companies don't want you

27:01

to not use their platform. they're going to continue to entice you and they're going to give you more features and make you more dependent. So, just like every other technology pattern we've seen, we have to choose how to take our time back and how to take our lives back. And this is why we're thinking partners. So, if we haven't done the work on it ourselves, it's going to be really hard for us to take that to our learners. >> So, it's like a it's it's there's three people in the classroom. Now, as a tutor, there's there'll be three Well, not people, but like there's three >> Yeah. There's a digital brain and two real brains. >> Exactly. >> Is that what we're talking about? Is that it will be assisted learning? And the teacher, the teacher/thinking partner is going to be quite um up to speed on on all the prompts and how to use AI and how to make sure it doesn't get slopp. Is that the idea? >> Yeah. So, just how to navigate it and how to use it for the best part of that particular task. I mean, that's that's one of the biggest questions. Um uh I don't know if you want to stop sharing that now but if you think about what the um what the when we go to do a task it's not always going to be AI that we need to use right so it's about how what what actually why would we use it I mean that's the first question I mean is this something that even needs AI to be involved like I've I've seen teachers tell me that they're getting students are doing reflection tasks using AI they're getting the AI to reflect for them you know that kind of stuff right we need to stop that and tracks like we need to be really conscious of why we're using the AI and what it's taking from us when we outsource everything to it and that's the piece that is the conversation. So less about prompts more about well why would you use an LLM for this and why would you use a you know this for another tool for something else. So yes because the the the problem we've got is that the way that we actually learn to think is through writing. Writing is one of the biggest tools to thinking. And so if we take that out of the students lives and we don't let them write and feel their way through those writing processes and if we as adults lose our craft because we've stopped writing, then we stop being able to think. And this is where people have not connected the dots enough because that's one of our ways we communicate and understand the world. We I'm I'm an audio person. So like I I I do get a lot of my thinking out through my voice and I talk and that's how I I do a lot of voice notes with friends. cuz I'm not a big journaler, but and because that's how my my my brain works. But equally, I do write and I do know when I sit down to write and I and I try and put together some ideas, that's how I'm thinking through the world, thinking through that problem. And so the reason we're seeing so much slop is because the skip the thinking part's been skipped. >> So say that again. >> Sorry. Sorry, say that. What was that last point? >> So we're seeing so much slop because people are just outsourcing all the thinking bit. So they're saying, "Oh, you know, I can create all these articles for my for my brand." And they're just telling Claude, "Write an article on this, this, this, and this." With no input of their own. So it's slop

30:00

because it's just a formula that the AI has create scraped on how to write. When you sit down to write about something you're passionate about, you don't write it the same way an AI will because it will come from the different layers of your thinking. So you'll be able to read it and go, "Oh, yeah. I've read some of Bianca's stuff before. She she often gets on her soap box about this thing. So, I can see why she said that cuz she's got a perspective over here that I know about, right? And so, I use AI to assist me, but it's not to write it. So, I will content dump the whole piece into cuz I speak it out. Then, it still takes me an hour and a half to get that to where I would actually publish it because it's it needs to come from my stories. It needs to come from my the way that I process information. And this is the bit that we're lucky because we learned how to write beforehand. And so our educators have to be really careful and our parents as well need to think through. Make your kids write with pen and paper every now and then. Get them to sit down and try and think. It hurts, right? It hurts for a reason because it's actually the thinking, right? We need to push ourselves to do that. >> This is interesting. So when you said writing equals thinking, it's, you know, where did where does that even come from? I've never heard that before, but it makes sense. Yes, I'm thinking and I'm writing because I can't think and not write. So is it like it's it's the practice of movement, pen, brain thinking and it's strengthening >> what >> it's how our cognit like it's how we join the dots because as soon as you have to think how to construct the sentence and how to flow the sentence from the last sentence, you're actually connecting your ideas. So you're going through that process. It's part of it's part of how we get to being able to analyze and critically think because we've sat down and had to think it through, >> right? >> But what what is a pen? What is a journal? What are you even talking about? That's going to like disappear completely, right? Like I haven't journal. I do enjoy it. I do more typing. I definitely find myself using my phone for everything. But yeah, I'm always taking notes. I'm always like planning my day. You know, I've got my booklet here and things like that. But in terms of yeah, I've never thought about sitting down and instead of going to chat GDP or AI now, I guess I could just go, hang on a second, what if I just wrote the prompt here on my page and then I ask myself the question first. >> Exactly. Exactly. >> Who would have thought? Who would have thought? [laughter] >> And maybe that I can go ask a friend or read a book. What do you >> What? >> And then pause before we continue. The first way we as entrepreneurs introduce ourselves when we walk into a room, it's our energy, right? People feel that. And secondly, it's our face. How healthy do we look? So for the entrepreneurs out there who care about how they show up, I'd love to share with you. Personally, I've been utilizing some Korean skincare products now just for over a month, and I had no idea about them um up until, you know, even just two months ago. But it's by far one of the best investments I've made for my skin. I feel it's literally making me look younger and it has this like glossy super fresh look.

33:01

And so this is the number one exported Korean beauty brand and skincare line in the world. The ingredients are second to none. Even pregnant pregnant women can utilize them because out there there's so many products that have toxins in them that really make our face not healthy over a long period of time. And so if you're out there and you want to match the energy that you output with how healthy you look, you can try all these products risk-f free for 30 days. If you don't like them, send them back and get all your money back. If you're out there, if you're curious, check out the link below to learn. Let's get back to the episode. >> Two years and we've already forgotten how to do that, right? Two, it's been two years since we had these LLMs in our life. And you know, I find myself constantly like stopping myself before I open it up and go, "No, I just no, just write the email." Right? Like, >> great point. >> You know, the amount of people who are telling me they've got these bots inside their emails writing all their emails, I'm like, there's no way you're going to catch me having a bot write my emails. Now, that doesn't mean I don't use AI for big long emails, like project emails and things like that. I talk in what I need and it structures it. It's fine. But I'm not going to sit there all day. I I'm going to write back to you. like it's going to be my words like >> yeah you're only going to get an AI generated email when it's got lots of meat that needs to be organized you know so yeah and this is where we we we have to decide how we use it and this is why AI literacy and I think back to the breakthrough moment to tie it back to the conversation at the beginning is that you know here I was an educator I've gone I want to go do business because I want to go and affect the system from the outside in I go off and you don't know where you're going to land when you start these journeys and then you here we are you've got a company at 7 years old and I'm like, "Oh my god, the biggest thing to ever hit education has just hit." And guess what? It needs it needs a foundational level of literacy, which is core foundational teaching so that we don't mess this up. And so I went, "Huh, I love that. That's my stuff." Like foundational knowledge and having these deep conversations with people about it. There are no right answers right now. There is no right way to do this thing. We are in a beautiful moment in history where we're going to look back and go, "Wow, we survived that and we thrived in it or we didn't thrive in it." And we have an opportunity to let it help our system in the best way. So, I love the fact that I got to this point in my career at this particular moment cuz I went, "Oh, yeah. This is so my stuff." Like, I love this conversation. And it really invigorated me again to talk about education because after so long in the space, you do feel like you're a bit of a, you know, head head against a brick wall but having this challenge systems at a core level is one of the best things we can hope for. >> So interesting. So you you gave me two graphics. I've shared one graphic. This is the second graphic. >> Yes. >> And what exactly is going on here before AI and after AI? What's the difference? >> Yeah. So one of the biggest things we need to realize for educators and for everyone to be honest, it's not just education. I mean I'll come at it from

36:01

that lens. But I use this graphic to talk about assessment and back to what are we trying to do? We're trying to do transformation. A lot of our assessments before have still been quite crap to be honest because they weren't really about transformation. They were about hitting some sort of knowledge metric. So this graphic is about AI not raising the ceiling as in it did not um give us something that's going to make everything better. It just meant everybody could get to average. So it did it lowered the floor which meant it's easier. You just jump on the bookcase and you get to the top. So an A. So for example, I'll give it like terms an A before LLMs in a school. So just go with letters. An A or a HD. Now most students in the class can get to that A because they have a tool that gets them there. So we didn't AI hasn't done this. It just let everybody get to the top. Right? This is why we have >> we were already aiming. We were already aiming for as high as we could get to. And now it's it's allowing more people to get to the top. >> Exactly. So it's allowing allowing everyone to be a writer a writer. It's allow it's allowing a lot more content to be produced. You know the amount of times on my Instagram I'm getting told I could do a faceless YouTube channel with AI content. It's like god I could not think of anything worse. Right? But that's what's happening. People are doing faceless AI channels, YouTube channels, and they're outperforming people like you and I who are busting our balls every day to write really good content that's authentic. And these outperforming bots because they've just got content generation behind them with scale and they've got logorithms and they're just playing off the game. So in education, this means well if this was an A and now everybody can get an A, what's the new A? Right? And this is where the assessment design piece comes in. So, you know, empathy to all the educators out there who are dealing with this because you're having to really rethink every single piece of that education journey, not only the content, but how do you actually assess the transformation? Which is why I'm excited because we've wanted to have that conversation for a long time because a lot of our assessments have been pretty crap to be frank, right? Even in our higher education institutions, they've been pretty lame. You can, you know, you can get through on not a lot of work, right? In lots of places. here. Well, now everyone's there. So, what are we going to do next? We have to raise the bar again. We have to say, what is it you're actually assessing? And that means taking personal responsibility as a subject matter expert as well in that moment to say, well, what value are you offering? Because if my chat GBT can tell me the answer to this question in 3 seconds flat and you take three days to reply to my email, why why are you here, professor? Yeah. And this is where the human element comes back in. So we have always and this is where nothing has really changed except for all the noise. People buy from people. People learn from people. PE learning hasn't changed. Sales hasn't changed. But every all the

39:01

tools have gotten in the way and made us think it all has. In the end, I will learn the same way as most humans on the planet have learned. But I have a lot more things and barriers I need to overcome to get to that place because now we have, you know, an Instagram feed that is trying to get your attention and is built on your like neuroscience is behind that. Like that's we have we're up against neuroscientists daily. We've got lots and lots of pressures in our lives and dings and economic pressures and society pressures and we are in a situation where we're in a pressure cooker as human beings. It has never been so hard to actually sit and be still and be quiet. And what does learning need? It needs you to be still and be quiet and to think and it needs you to sit together and it needs you to talk together. And it is time for those things to happen. So, if you're ever worried about your organization or institution not hitting markers of learning, just carve some more time out for your people to talk to each other because we learn from each other like you are on the podcast and we when we talk, when we have dialogue, when we hear other people's points of view, when we get a chance to speak, I'm learning just by being able to speak today with you cuz I'm getting all this out of my system for the day. And we're having an opportunity to have a dialogue and that's actually always been the fundamental. It's always been stories. It's always been narrative. It's always been sharing. So, we get too bogged down with all the other crap. It's not that important. >> Yeah, we were joking about it with technology. It's why you send me the graphics. >> Yeah, we never get it to share. [laughter] >> We We've got so much going against us. We've got passwords. We've got multiffactor identification. Now, we've got robots asking us if we're robots. I'm constantly battling, you know, just to run an online business, as you know, Zach, is insane. the amount of I have to deal with administratively and technologally just to get this like my team working on the day. You might as well I'd rather be back in an office to be honest and bring them all in. Like there was a point where our SAS bill got higher than it would be if I had put the whole team in a bloody office in a m in a city, right? So here I was thinking I've got this advantage being in a remote company, but we got to a point where, you know, the per seat pricing when I had contractors was getting so high on all my pieces of tech that I was like, "Hang on a minute. If we had an office, I would be paying out this stuff." So this is this happens all the time. We can't predict the future, but we have patterns to look at from the past. And AI is about to do this in everyone's organization. You're about to wake up and go, "Well, the ROI is not there, so this sucks." And then you have to figure out how to use it from here on. >> So that's that's a cool thing to talk about, too. >> It's your prediction about that. Tell me more about that. You think people are going to you think it's going to it's a bubble. It's going to burst. Michael Bur uh who predicted the big short. >> Yes. >> There's a whole movie made about him. You know, he's he's uh >> he's shorting >> he's shorting AI. >> Well, not all of them, but like some. Yeah. >> Oh, yeah. People will always find each other again. They're not going to be replaced by machines. we're not going to allow it. It's at the moment even just

42:00

even the most sophisticated AI system has this human in the loop element. Now, there's some doomsday predictors that are saying human in the loop isn't even going to be a thing in a 2 years time because they the AIs will go into a little room and they'll be the humans and they'll just kind of figure it out in a little ecosystem of agents. Um I I don't buy it. Um cuz I don't think again as we're seeing by the the kind of movements at the moment back to this kind of nostalgic '9s and people are getting home phones and they're taking away their smartphones and they're going back to real life and the young people are going you millennials are really messed this up. I don't want my phone. I don't want any of this crap. I'm going back to, you know, hiking with my friends on the weekend and I'm disconnecting. And there's sober dance parties and there's all these things happening that are popping up that are telling us that people do not want to be on their phones all the time. They don't want to be in online communities zooming each other on weekends. They want to be together. And learning is the same. Companies are the same. And I think we're already seeing a push back. There's a whole lot of conversations about ROIs in these big companies just not not coming to fruition because you're taking out people, but then you're getting you're retraining these people to then train the AIS, but then you're also causing a lot more problems from what the AIs are doing to create more jobs over here. So, the people are not getting replaced. They're redistributing in some areas, but we're also going to get really fed up with it because, you know, everything is always fine until someone loses an eye or the technology goes down like >> [laughter] >> go to the airport. Online check-in's fine until the machines don't work. So, >> oh gosh. Yes. No, this is great. This is a breath of fresh air. Even though, you know, it's like, ah, it's good. It's it's level-headed. It's critical thinking. It's realist. It's realism. It's uh it's it's backed by education and real world experience. So, no, I I want the future where we have more wholesome old school things, card games and, you know, outside playing and, you know, less tech and more campfires. I'm all for it. I'm all for it. >> There's an analogy I had recently. So, if you think about it, right? So, remember when the calculator came out? That was probably around um like late '7s, ' 80s. So obviously you and I were not here teaching or being professionals but from the teachers from the day they were really stressed about the calculator. They were like the calculator is going to kill the children's minds. It's going to like it's going to take away math. Everyone's going to be ma can't do maths. Blah blah blah blah blah. Okay. Calculator came. I think we're all okay. Right. Then we got Excel and we've got Excel spreadsheets. And could you imagine running a business without Excel spreadsheets? There were people that have businesses today that ran their businesses before Excel spreadsheets. So they did it right. They did it with a checkbook and a number book and a you know ruler and a pen and a pencil and the old school maths right they did it. We will think about AI very soon and we won't even think about AI would just the thing will just be there that the output will just be there. So the spreadsheet will just exist. You don't go to somebody when they present you their business numbers what tool did

45:00

you use to make this right you just accept the numbers because there was a tool used to get to the numbers. So, at the moment, we're in the part of tech where we're talking about AI all the time because it's the thing we're trying to understand and place in a way that fits into society. It won't be seen soon. It'll just be behind things that happen. And there's lots of people who've been working AI 20, 30 years, and they're just all going, "It's already been here. You guys just figured it out when LLM hit you, right?" So, they're just face planting all over the place, probably annoyed at all the rest of us for jumping on the bandwagon. They're like, "Yeah, we know. We know. We've been building this tech forever." Okay. So, we're all just grappling as a collective because we can see it finally, but it's not going to be the conversation soon. Like, I hope to go to a business conference in 2 years time and hardly hear the word AI because it will just have advanced things into a position where we're just talking about the thing, not what was behind it. We're just talking about what that innovation allowed us to do, right? So I I'm able to do financial modeling and projection on a new product and show that to you on a slide deck and you don't need to know that I used Excel and maybe my calculator for bits of it on my phone. Like that's not important. So this is where we need to remember we're in the fluttery head chicken cut off space right now where everybody's just trying to grapple with the actual tool and it will dissipate and then we'll just be living again. >> Super interesting. Now obviously you do use AI. So, what AIs do you use when you do? >> I'm pretty simple. I've got just the Claude and the Chad GBT. I have projects set up. I have, you know, some some skills, but not really. I haven't really done agents yet. I'm not really interested in having an agent run through my Google Drive and on my computer. I don't need agents at the moment for what I'm doing. Um, you know, I use the general kind of I use granola for um meetings because it's not invasive. I kind of hate this kind of AI poking its head into people's meetings all the time and announcing itself. I tell people I'm, you know, I've got granola on, but I just allow it to do its thing in the background. Um, so yeah, and we've used it a bit in our learning design for different pieces. I like the audio stuff. I think the audio AI voiceovers can be really helpful. Um, I do a lot of camera work myself, so I've kind of it's easier to go into a studio and film on a green screen than use any kind of AI avatar. So, I just do all my own filming still because I just think it's not it's not how humans learn. I don't want to look at an avatar on a screen. Like, I just don't. So, why would I put that in front of anyone I'm teaching? So, you know, it's it's a it's about I use it as a as a thinking partner, you know. So, I use my AI to like I'll say, "This is what I want to do. Tell me how I think you think I should do this. You know, what kind of steps am I missing? This is what I think." Da da da da. And so, I have a look a really good conversation with it. And I don't sort of outsource too much of my entire thinking to it, but it's becomes my little buddy during the day. And I've called mine Todd. So Todd and I, you know, we we have a good relationship. Yeah. >> It's awesome. Oh, that is super interesting. So from Oh gosh. Yeah. I've

48:02

never seen this AI Notepad granola thing. That is that the one? The AI notad? >> That's called Yeah, it's called granola. Yeah. Yeah. It just kind of hangs out in the background. It's pretty cool. Does notes for you. >> Like a big big sticky pad. >> Yeah. And I use whisper flow a bit as well cuz I love talking. Um I'm much better talker than I am typer. I type too fast for my own brain. I type too slow for my own brain. So I find typing really hard work. Um yeah >> I'm always so great. So good. >> No this is great advice. Really appreciate all this. Uh from who is listening who should reach out to you? Who's a perfect client? What problems do you solve? I'll put all your links around here of course. >> Yeah. Yeah. So my personal website has kind of it's kind of like my link tree. So it's got all the kind of links to what we're doing. I think for the moment I mean the most the most important thing is if you've in an organization who is thinking about AI literacy and hasn't been having these conversations with their staff whether you're an institution of education or you're any other corporate or or government body. I think you got to be having these conversations like we have to start these conversations about literacy and literacy means the foundations around ethics and judgment and what is it what does it really mean to engage with these tools because they're going to arm your people up to be conscious and to be able to then engage with the right tool for the right job make all those judgment calls down the track and and really kind of help you not get into a situation where you're wasting a lot of time and money and spinning on AR. It it can be a time sucker. It can be a money sucker. So you want to get your people really thinking through it and also alleviating some of that fear around their job being taken cuz a lot of people are a bit worried right now and that's fine and and you should be in a way considering what is your career look like and I always advocate for people to check in on that. What kind of learning do I need to do to stay where I need to be or where I want to go next and really having those proactive conversations with your team. So if you're in that position and you want to talk to me about running workshops, we do a lot of workshops. We have a program that we're able to kind of embed into your organization. It's very kind of adaptable and contextualizable, which is a word I made up recently. I don't think it really exists. Can we can we can add context to all of our modules to your particular context is what I'm trying to say. So, if you're in that situation, yeah, reach out because we're doing a lot of work with larger organizations to help them bring up the skills of their team. >> Contextable. >> Contextualizable. Yeah. [laughter] >> No, it's a new word now. They're all made up anyway, right? Yeah. >> Yeah. Um, excellent. So, I'll put everybody please if you're resonating, reach out to Bianca, get in touch. >> Um, my final question, look, you've shared your breakthrough moment. What challenges or suggestions do you have for others to also have a breakthrough? Something something they could do this week, this month, this year. >> You have to get out of your comfort zone. There is no other way. You're not going to get a breakthrough moment if you're just staying within the 5 km radius of your house and doing the same thing every week that you did the week before. Um, you just you you can't you you're if you're feeling stuck, change your environment. >> You've always got to change your environment.

51:01

>> Um, if I'm ever feeling stuck, I just even if it's just to change it up for the cafe, I'll just go down to the cafe for 3 hours and I'll work from there just to move out of the environment. So, that's a small micro thing you can do on a daily basis. If you wake up every day and you sit in the same room, you look at the same screen and you do the same thing and you eat the same breakfast, you're going to consistently have the same things. So mix it up. Go away for a week, work in front of the ocean, do whatever you need to do if you need to change it up. But nothing's going to happen if it if every day looks the same. >> For sure. Great advice. Thank you so much for your time. >> You know, we've covered uh some Yeah, you're welcome. We've covered some really important issues and conversations. This is, I guess, the beginning hopefully for all of us to continue the conversation with friends and family, work, and things like that to start talking about what this really does mean. I liked what you said. You said like everyone's still just trying to figure this out. We're all in this bit of a bubble. We're all just like in in this interesting phase, which >> yeah, I think everyone's trying to trying to portray that they have it all figured out, including myself, you know? I think I'm like an AI master, but I don't, you know, but then everyone's kind of just doing their own thing and, you know, just because someone's written a book and and has has a lot of insight on AI, you know, I do see them as an expert for sure, but at the same time, no one knows what's around the corner. But as you said, history doesn't repeat, but it it's it's very similar. Um, or it rhymes, they say, too. So, it's it's important to look at the past. So, everybody at home, please share this with somebody who you know who would benefit. What has been your aha or breakthrough moment? Please put it into the comments. >> Any final words before we >> I just think I'm calling everyone to be a lifelong learner. Lots of adults say they are. So, this is the time to step up, right? We all have to step up and lead. And especially if you're in a situation where you are in a leadership position in your career and you've gotten to the point that you're able to influence others. This is our step up moment. So, we all have to do it together. >> It's so funny you said step up on my whiteboard here. Has step up on here, too. So, in the flow, synchronistic. >> Thank you so much for your time. Appreciate this. And everybody at home, we'll see you next time on the Breakthrough Moment podcast. Over and out of everyone. Sorry.

Zac Deane, host of The Breakthrough Moment Podcast
Meet your host

Zac Deane

Host of The Breakthrough Moment Podcast
Founder of The Podcast Tour

I was the kid who hid in the school library, terrified of being seen. Acting classes at eighteen began a different path. Six years of Wednesday presentations, expos across Australia and full-time live television taught me how to help people share what they know.

Today I ask entrepreneurs, investors and professionals about the moment that changed everything, then explore a lesson someone else can use. Through The Podcast Tour, I help business owners share their expertise through podcast conversations and content.

Read my story or get the free Breakthrough Moment workbook.

“The confidence people see now came after the practice. Not before it.”

Your story could be next

What is your
breakthrough moment?

Have a story and a lesson that could help someone else? Meet Zac for a 15-minute podcast chat to explore your story and whether the show is the right fit.

Book a 15-minute podcast chat

A conversation to explore the fit. No recording on this call.